Select Page

If you’ve ever been in your basement or someone else’s and had to use the bathroom, you may have been petrified to look around and see no toilet in sight. Having to rush upstairs to reach the closest toilet is not something anyone wants to be doing when nature calls. The best way to address this is simple: add a toilet to your basement!

Adding a toilet to your basement can sound daunting at first, but it’s pretty easy with the right choice of toilet system. It will also be a great renovation choice for both home valuation as well as functionality. Adding a half bathroom to your basement, for example, can raise the value of your house if you ever go to sell it, and having a toilet available to you when you’re spending time in the basement can be a godsend.

There are many factors to keep in mind when you’re looking for the best toilets for your basement and there are a vast number of options available. After looking through all sorts of different options, we’ve come up with the five best toilets for basements available on the market today.

Our Pick for Best Basement Toilet:

$85.25
Saniflo 023 Sanicompact Self-Contained Toilet
150 Reviews
Saniflo 023 Sanicompact Self-Contained Toilet
  • Build a half bathroom for residential applications
  • Vertical pumping up to 9-Feet and 100-Feet horizontally
  • Allows the connection of a sink. Toilet that uses a minimum amount of water
  • Uses just 1-Gallon of water per flush
  • Stylish toilet seat with chrome hinges included.

The overall best option for a basement toilet is the Saniflo 023 Sanicompact. Due to its sleek look, compact design, easy install, efficient performance, and manufacturer’s warranty, it comes out as our number one choice for adding a toilet to your basement.

Read on to see our in-depth reviews of the five best toilets for basements, including our top pick, available on the market today!

Saniflo 023 Sanicompact Toilet Review

Being our top choice for the best toilet for a basement, the Saniflo 023 Sanicompact checks almost everything off the list that we threw at it.

With its sleek look and compact design, this is the perfect option for any area, regardless of how tight of a squeeze the toilet is going to be. Without the typical water tank on the back of the toilet that you’d see on most units, this toilet takes up very little space while offering a modern, minimalistic design perfect for any application.

Known for the ease of install of their products, this Saniflo toilet can be installed by just about anyone, regardless of if you’re a professional plumber or haven’t plumbed a day in your life.

This unit is designed to be connected to a sink drain or some other water source, which will be used to allow 1-gallon of water to flow into the macerating tank to be used per flush, saving water over other options.

Saniflo is easily the most commonly purchased brand of basement toilets, and the Sanicompact is the best unit that they offer. With its durable construction, comfortable seating, and compact size, it is the perfect toilet for use in your basement.

Product Specifications

  • 62.2 pounds
  • 18.25 x 14.5 x 25.75 inches
  • Elongated bowl
  • 1.0 gallons per flush
  • Electric-powered, no batteries

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Compact size, perfect for areas with limited space
  • Water-saving
  • Quiet operation
  • Easier to clean since there is no water tank
  • 2-year warranty

Cons:

  • Toilet cannot flush if the power goes out since there are no batteries

Overall, the Saniflo 023 Sanicompact is the best basement toilet on the market today. The pros heavily outweigh the cons with this toilet and there isn’t a lot of negativity coming from customers who have purchased this toilet. No matter the application or price range you’re looking at, be sure to include the Sanicompact among your choices!

Liberty Pumps ASCENT II-ESW Toilet Review

Coming in as our second-ranked best basement toilet, the Liberty Pumps ASCENT II-ESW is a great option to add a toilet to your basement.

Coming from another big player in the macerating toilet game, this option is one of the most technologically up-to-date units on the market. With their proprietary RazorCut technology within the macerator, the ASCENT II-ESW offers outstanding performance for a basement toilet and is much easier to clean than other options.

A unique feature about this toilet is its removable access panel which allows easy access to anything that may need to be maintained, something that the other options on this list do not have. Combine this feature with its efficient water use, this is one of the best available toilets for use in your basement.

This Liberty Pumps unit is also the only one listed here that has a battery as a backup to run the pump just in case the power goes out or there is an issue with the electricity. This will allow you to still flush the toilet without electricity, a second feature that the other options are lacking. 

Product Specifications

  • 121 pounds
  • 29.75 x 20.0 x 32.25 inches
  • Elongated bowl
  • 1.28 gallons per flush
  • 9V battery needed as a backup

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Highly efficient
  • Can still be flushed if the power goes out
  • Removal of access panel makes service a breeze
  • RazorCut technology to improve the grinding process of the blades

Cons:

  • Noisier than other options
  • Macerator has been known to grind for too long and set off its alarm

The single biggest drawback of the Liberty Pumps ASCENT II-ESW is that it is noticeably noisier than most other options, but that may not be as big of a deal to some depending on the application. With all the unique features that this toilet has in comparison to some of the other options, a little bit of added noise shouldn’t be the nail in the coffin – it’s a great option for adding a toilet to your basement!

Saniflo SaniPLUS: Macerating Upflush Toilet Kit Review

Number 3 in our rankings for the best toilets for basements is the Saniflo SaniPLUS: Macerating Upflush Toilet Kit. Another option from Saniflo, this toilet kit is the perfect addition to your basement project. With the ability to provide drainage for not only the toilet itself but also a sink and shower, this kit is exactly what you need to add a bathroom to any space.

As mentioned above, Saniflo products are known for their easy installation, and this unit is no exception. Weighing under 100 pounds for both pieces, this lightweight toilet can be installed by one person with relative ease. Once you’ve got it installed, you’re bound to be happy with its white finish that goes well with any bathroom setup.

Similar to the other options we’ve seen, the Saniflo SaniPLUS is efficient, only using 1.6 gallons per flush. Not only are the flushes efficient, they are also among the quietest in the industry, drawing no attention to the toilet after it’s been used.

Product Specifications

  • 99.7 pounds
  • 28.75 x 17.75 x 31.0 inches
  • Elongated bowl
  • 1.6 gallons per flush
  • Electric-powered, no batteries

Pros:

  • Full system, capable of hooking up a shower and sink drain to be pumped out
  • an be installed 15 feet below the sewer line, perfect for basements
  • Easy to install
  • Quiet operation
  • 2-year warranty

Cons:

  • Toilet cannot flush if the power goes out since there are no batteries
  • Low water levels in the bowl, may require more cleaning

Overall, this is one of the best options on the market and can help you to install a bathroom almost anywhere you want with its ability to offer drainage capabilities to both a sink and shower. Hook this toilet up in your basement, drain your sink and shower into it, and you’ve just added a full bathroom to your basement while doing a lot less plumbing!

Jabsco 37010 Series Electric Marine Toilet Review

Another great option for the best toilet for basements, the Jabsco 37010 Series Electric Marine Toilet comes in as our 4th highest ranked unit. While typically used in marine applications as the name implies, this toilet will work perfectly in your basement as well. 

It is incredibly lightweight coming in at less than 40 pounds, yet durable enough to last many years. Its compact size and lightweight design make it perfect for the DIY’er who would prefer to get a toilet installed in their basement by themselves rather than pay to hire anyone to install it. The standard bowl design also helps to make this toilet compact and easily fit into any space you want to put it.

The Jabsco 37010 Series employs a push button flush that will continuously flush until you let go of the button, unlike the other options with specific volumes of water used per flush. While being less efficient this way, you never have to fear anything being leftover in the toilet that a smaller flush may have missed.

This works in conjunction with a built-in backflow preventer to ensure that once something has left the unit, it does not come back in and lead to a mess.

Product Specifications

  • 36 pounds
  • 29.0 x 14.4 x 14.8 inches
  • Standard bowl
  • 3 feet of vertical pumping
  • Electric-powered, no batteries

Pros:

  • Lightweight, it’s the lightest unit on this list
  • The bowl is compact, yet the seats are comfortable like a normal toilet
  • Stainless steel shaft and magnet-type motor are fully enclosed and built to last

Cons:

  • Typically built for marine applications, but it works great as a basement option
  • Older models have been prone to motors seizing, so be sure to get a new one

With how compact and lightweight it is, the Jabsco 37010 Series Electric Marine Toilet is the perfect option for anyone looking to install a toilet system in their basement. It is a bit noisy when running, but this is due to the constant flush and high capacity macerator, which may be a worthy trade-off in the end!

Lift Assure American Elongated Macerating Toilet Review

Rounding out our list of the five best basement toilets is the Lift Assure American Elongated Macerating Toilet. Another option with enough input valves to allow you to pump water from your sink and shower as well as the toilet. This is the perfect choice to add a full bathroom to your basement.

The most unique feature of this toilet is its dual capability flush buttons. One button will do a half flush, while the other does a full flush. The smaller flush volume is suited for liquid waste, and the full flush is used for solid waste. This allows you to save even more water – even though the full flush only uses 1.28 gallons per flush!

The Lift Assure American Macerating Toilet features a seat height of 15″, which is low for an average toilet. While being family-friendly and allowing kids to use it more easily. This can also make it more difficult for elderly people or those who are taller to use it as it sits lower than normal.

Product Specifications

  • 110 pounds
  • 28.0 x 15.0 x 28.0 inches
  • Elongated bowl
  • 1.28 gallons per flush
  • Electric-powered, no batteries

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Features half-flush and full-flush capabilities to save water
  • Powerful enough system to pump the toilet, sink, and shower

Cons:

  • The low 15” seat height can be harder for elderly or taller individuals to use
  • There have been complaints of having difficulty reaching customer service

In conclusion, the Lift Assure American Elongated Macerating Toilet is a great option to add to your basement bathroom addition and it will help you save time and effort on plumbing everything together. With few cons and a lot of good things about it, don’t let its fifth-place ranking fool you – it’s a great option when you’re looking for a basement toilet!

Basement Toilet Buying Guide

.

You may be on the fence about buying a basement toilet as you try to decide whether or not it’s the right purchase for you. To help you understand what you should be keeping in mind while looking into adding a toilet to your basement, read on to learn more about what basement toilets actually are, a general look into the installation process, and some of the typical questions that people have about the product.

What is a basement toilet, and why should you get one?

.

As the name implies, a basement toilet is a toilet system that is ideal for installation in your basement. Due to either limited space, limited plumbing, or concrete flooring that you don’t want to break, deciding to install a basement toilet may be the best option for you.

With toilet systems designed for basement use, especially for use in areas that weren’t originally made for a toilet, these specialized products really shine. One of the biggest differences in how basement toilets work is their flushing and waste management mechanisms. Rather than flushing the waste products (human waste and toilet paper) downward through the sewage line like a normal toilet, basement toilet systems temporarily store the waste in what is known as a macerating tank.

The macerator grinds the waste product up before flushing it upwards or sideways to connect with the sewage line elsewhere. This difference in flushing direction is where the term seen a few times earlier in the article “upflush” comes from. This makes these toilets ideal for adding a bathroom somewhere that wasn’t originally designed to be a bathroom since the regular plumbing needed for normal toilets, such as sewage and ventilation pipes, is not necessary.

If you’re wanting to add a toilet to your basement, or even if you’re converting an old closet space to a small bathroom, any one of the best toilets for basements from the list above are perfect for you. You won’t need to plumb the main sewage line in, they can be easily installed on concrete slab flooring, and they are typically easier to install overall than a normal toilet that you would put in your bathroom!

How to Install a Basement Toilet

.

Installing a basement toilet is typically not as much work as installing a regular toilet in a normal bathroom, especially if you end up choosing one of the best toilets for basements we reviewed in this article. With a normal bathroom, toilet installation needs to be done so that it drains into the main sewage line when flushed. This is why bathrooms are typically located in the same area of the house on different floors so that the sewage and ventilation lines can be run straight down.

With the macerating technology seen in all of our recommended basement toilet systems, you can install the toilet in a different location and then pump the waste to the sewage lines separately. This enables you to put it where you want, rather than being limited to only installing the toilet where the existing sewage and ventilation lines are located.

While the particulars of each toilet and each brand may differ, the general process for installing a macerating toilet is fairly straightforward and can be broken down into five main steps:

  1. Decide on which toilet system you want and where you’re going to install it. This can be one of the hardest steps of the process, but it is the most important before moving forward!
  2. Connect the discharge pipes from the toilet to the sewage line. You will want to get this connection done first, as you want to be sure it’s heading towards the main soil stack before you start using it.
  3. Connect your toilet system to its water source. Whether you are using a nearby sink, or something on the other side of the wall, run a water line from the source to the toilet so that it can flush.
  4. Connect the toilet pump to its power source. For the system to run, the pump needs to be plugged in. It is recommended to use an outlet with a Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) to power the pump.
  5. Vent the macerator. You’ll want to vent the macerator to your main vent system unless you opted for our number one choice which doesn’t need venting. You’ll just need to make sure the ventilation is up to code, but it can go pretty much anywhere that is applicable.

Frequently Asked Questions About Basement Toilets

.

Q: What is the biggest difference between a basement toilet and a normal toilet?

A: The biggest difference between the two toilet types is the macerating pumps that are included with the basement toilets looked at here. These pumps can cut/grind the solid waste into an easily movable state, allowing it to be pumped upwards through piping into the sewage pipes. This is the main factor to look at while shopping for the best toilets for basements.

Q: Why are macerating/upflush toilets favorable for basement use compared to normal toilets?

A: Due to their ability to grind solid matter down to make it easier to move to sewage mains via pumping, these toilets are ideal for locations where there isn’t existing sewage piping installed. Normal toilets drain downwards through the sewage main, requiring a hole in the floor to drain through. Macerating toilets can be installed in any location and have its sewage pumped to wherever the sewage lines are, even upwards.

Q: Are basement toilets worth the extra cost compared to a regular toilet?

A: Although the actual toilet prices are significantly higher than a normal toilet, basement toilets are usually fully operational on their own with much less plumbing needed when compared to a normal toilet. When you take all the costs into account associated with fully plumbing an entirely new bathroom like you would need to with a normal toilet, you’ll be spending far more doing so than going with a basement toilet system to begin with!

Final Thoughts

When it comes to basement toilet systems, there is an abundance of choices for you to sift through to find the perfect unit. You could potentially spend hours of your time researching the best units on the market. With all sorts of different factors going into the best basement toilet for you such as style, efficiency, price, installation, and extra features, researching this topic could go on for longer than you’d like. Luckily, we’ve done the research for you.

You can’t go wrong with any of our five best toilets for basements that we’ve gone over, each with their specific pros and cons. Depending on the style you’re going for, the amount you are willing to spend, and what kinds of additional features that you want, you’ll likely find the perfect option for you on this list. While each toilet is not perfect for everyone and every situation, rest assured you’ll be happy with any of the options listed here!

Last update on 2020-08-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API